Reg readers speak out on Thin Client technology

Reg readers speak out on Thin Client technology Reg readers speak out on Thin Client technology
January 24, 2017

Reg readers speak out on Thin Client technology

Survey Results Managing PC estates is a time-consuming, expensive and thankless task. Better provisioning and management tools can obviously help, but implementing one or more of the various forms of desktop virtualisation available nowadays may also be beneficial.

 The virtualisation option, and particularly the use of hardware-based thin clients in that context, was the subject of a recent Reg reader survey. From this we learned that over their many years of existence, thin client devices have found their place in many environments.

Relevant types of users and use cases called out in relation to this (in respondents' own words) include:

"Office administration staff."
"Operational and managerial staff using office or web based applications."
"General business users, help desk or call centre agents, and anyone else who needs a moderate and consistent set of applications."

The theme coming through here is the acknowledged role of thin clients in meeting the needs of employees with relatively undemanding application requirements. For users who spend most of their time accessing server or cloud based business applications, or performing lightweight tasks with Microsoft Office (email, word processing, etc), there's a good case for virtualising and centralising their Windows environment.

Apart from the management and support benefits of reducing complexity on the user's desk, doing away with the local "C: Drive" as part of the centralisation process also removes a security headache. With this in mind, it's not surprising to see users who frequently access sensitive or valuable data being identified as potential targets for thin client deployments. Examples here include:

"Senior management."
"Admin staff using sensitive data."
"Software development contractors so the source doesn't leave the organisation's core servers."

Then sticking with the theme of risk management, another potential benefit comes to the fore:

"Thin clients in a DR scenario."

What this comment is getting at is that it's a lot quicker and easier to get users up and running again if their desktops reside on a server independently of physical devices.

Beyond the "horizontal" categories of users and use cases we have touched on so far, a number of examples of vertical industry use of thin clients came through in the reader feedback and anecdotes:

"We use thin clients to replace the dodgy small form factor computers that are built-in to wall mounted display boards. Thin clients are much more reliable. They are also remotely controllable so the techs are safer - they're no longer working on top of ladders, in the ceiling and behind heavy displays."
"In healthcare the ability to turn many types of office workers into remote workers is hugely beneficial. Choosing a zero client that is effectively a streaming device is huge for the security of protected data. Freeing up office space and allowing management to have the ability to utilise home offices without compromising security makes our organisation nimbler. We are currently sending all of our medical coders home with zero clients."
"The best use of thin clients I have ever seen was in a school where a single machine souped up with RAM and caching lots of files as a terminal server could run circles around the usual fat clients."

Some of these industry-focused use cases appear very specific, but can be more broadly applied as the same "shapes" of requirement often crop up elsewhere. Here are some other examples that fall into this category:

"Kiosk mode for certain applications is good in schools."
"[Electronic signage] displaying looping video."
"Remote/branch office and POS terminals [in a retail environment]."
"Perfect solution for dusty environments."

But while many are clear on the potential, others in the study expressed concerns about the suitability of thin client technology to handle more demanding requirements in areas such as:

"Real-time video."
"Video analytics."
"Video conferencing."
"Heavy media editing scenarios."

Such perceptions are interesting given that networks, transport protocols, devices and software platforms have developed over the past few years to remove constraints in these areas (at least if you listen to desktop virtualisation solution vendors). Empty marketing promises, perhaps? You could be forgiven for thinking so when we also see references to "disappointing" real world experiences like these:

"Seen problems with thin clients deployed in a police control room that could not play back 999 calls. Thick clients had to be used to listen to recordings."
"Our experience with unified communications and thin clients is a bad one."

So what's going on? Well, some of the more qualified concerns and warnings provide a clue:

"Full-screen video is definitely not good with weak servers, slow networks or weak thin clients."
"A major 80k user plus company I worked for attempted to roll out thin clients to 40k users overnight, with no change in network infrastructure. It sucked."
"The worst result I have seen is [thin clients deployed] in a computer lab for students to edit media with Adobe Creative Suite, relying on the local graphics card to render video."
"Seen CAD on Citrix over a WAN link. The guy who implemented this should have been shot"
"It is not about the hardware thin clients on the desktop. It is about the back-end."

Such comments allude to the fact that many problems stem not from inherent limitations of the technology, but inadequacies in the supporting infrastructure and/or inappropriate configuration of one kind or another. Turning this logic on its head, one experienced reader told us:

"When coupled with a decent central server and a high quality network, thin clients are ideal for the majority of standard workers".

So does this mean that all of the problems we hear are down to ignorance or budgetary stinginess? Could thin client technology be used across the board if you just did it right? Of course not.

Mobile users who have to work in disconnected mode are clearly a non-starter for hardware-based thin clients. Furthermore, while techniques such as virtual to physical USB port mapping now work more reliably and flexibly, you can still run into peripheral connectivity problems depending on the kit you have in place and what you are trying to connect over which types of port. And for users with complex and frequently changing application needs, and those with requirements that simply can't tolerate the latency of even a relatively quick network (despite all the modern protocol trickery), thin clients just don't make sense. This reader comment is therefore very apt:

"Don't assume that [thin clients] are appropriate for all types of user"

Then beyond the user experience and other practicalities, you also have to do your arithmetic:

"One of the fallacies is the notion that lots of money will be saved by moving to thin clients. This kind of move offsets the cost of the hardware on the desk, but greatly increases the cost of infrastructure."

In order to make objective decisions in this space, it's important to add up all of the costs, from the desktop to the server, up through all layers of the hardware and software stack, and across the lifecycle from deployment to ongoing maintenance and support. Only then will you be able to figure out whether the benefits outweigh the investment.

Standing back, the overriding impression we get from this latest research, considering both the survey stats and the reader feedback listed above, is that the potential to exploit thin client technology is probably a lot broader than many imagine. Perceptions are often clouded by legacy experiences and knowledge, and perhaps also by more recent failures stemming from projects that weren't necessarily scoped and resourced as well as they should have been. If this rings true, it therefore might be time to take another look.

If you do this, though, we would urge you to review the role of thin client technology as part of an analysis of your end user computing needs more generally. The chances are, if you do your homework and get up to date on current solutions, you will see a potential place for all types of traditional and desktop virtualisation options. Thin client technology may be a key ingredient in the mix as you look to solve your desktop related challenges, but it has to be considered in its proper context.

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter all the required information, indicated by an asterisk (*). HTML code is not allowed.

209013 comments

  • Comment Link Elliot June 09, 2017 posted by Elliot

    Can I use your phone? http://www.hardmusica.pt/cheap-fluconazole-online.pdf can you buy diflucan over the counter in usa After the brothers’ act broke up, Mike emigrated to Florida, where he became a successful Miami nightclub owner, did much work for charity and wrote several books including a memoir, The Sunny Side Of Winters (2010). He eventually retired to Gloucestershire.
    http://www.fossiloberoendevg.se/buy-tamoxifen-for-research.pptx research nolvadex buy The payments, which have increased in recent months, show how Assad has sustained his ties with his main diplomatic defender, a relationship that has come under the spotlight this week as Western countries plan military action to punish him for suspected chemical weapons attacks on civilians.

    Report
  • Comment Link Hannah June 09, 2017 posted by Hannah

    How many weeks' holiday a year are there? http://www.fossiloberoendevg.se/buy-cheap-seroquel.pptx buy quetiapine xr Homebuilding stocks rallied on a report that U.S. industrialproduction rose in August as a bounce back in motor vehicleassembly lifted manufacturing output, a hopeful sign for theeconomy after growth got off to a slow start in the thirdquarter.
    http://www.glencar.ie/purchase-promethazine-codeine-syrup.pdf buy promethazine cough syrup "They told us they'd shelved it," said legislator BushraGohar, who raised the matter in the National Assembly. "Thereare violent groups operating openly in this country and theywant to ban objectionable content?"

    Report
  • Comment Link Lance June 09, 2017 posted by Lance

    Is it convenient to talk at the moment? http://www.tdic.it/10mg-nolvadex-on-cycle.pdf nolvadex for pct buy “The intermittent problems experienced by some of our customers yesterday has now been resolved,” said the operator. “Routine upgrade work on our 2G and 3G networks led to unexpected congestion affecting around 1% of O2 customers. We apologise to those customers and thank them for their patience.”
    http://www.hardmusica.pt/cheap-fluconazole-online.pdf cheap fluconazole for yeast infection Smith, who took the majority of the reps with the first team because it was his turn in the rotation, was 9-for-16 for 77 yards and a sack. The team scored 10 points with Sanchez at the helm and three with Smith, though the offense went for it on fourth-and-goal inside the 5-yard line on the first drive with the rookie at QB.

    Report
  • Comment Link Phillip June 09, 2017 posted by Phillip

    I'm not interested in football http://www.autoempleo.net/oxybutynine-order.pdf#prickly ditropan xl generic name A day after Gia Allemand's NBA boyfriend broke his silence and called his grief over her suicide a "roller coaster," the tragic "Bachelor" beauty's mom has confirmed their plans for a joint memorial foundation.
    http://www.scotland2000.com/where-to-buy-generic-strattera.pdf european pharmacy org buy strattera online Raikkonen brings with him a strong pedigree as a world class driver who can get the best out of any car, a reputation that is respected by Alonso but not seen as any extra motivation or one that will destabilize the team.

    Report
  • Comment Link Darrin June 09, 2017 posted by Darrin

    I'm doing an internship http://www.hollywoodrecords.com/dapoxetine-hydrochloride-specification.pptx tadalafil and dapoxetine reviews "Childcare is a vital part of our economic infrastructure that, alongside family support and flexible working, should give parents the choice to stay at home with their children when they are very small and to balance work and family as they grow older.
    http://www.glencar.ie/purchase-promethazine-codeine-syrup.pdf#virtue promethazine codeine online purchase The crotchety killer, who was convicted of first-degree murder, showed no remorse for what he did when he took the stand Monday, a decision derided by his own attorney. Spooner blamed Simmons’ mother, Patricia Larry, for the alleged theft, saying she made the boy steal the guns. The old man, who’d been robbed prior, had no evidence the boy entered his home other than grainy surveillance video that showed a black suspect.

    Report
  • Comment Link Garland June 09, 2017 posted by Garland

    It's OK http://www.aisleplanyourday.com/solaraze-vs-voltaren-gel.pdf#beaten solaraze gel discount coupons Jordan, which imports 97 percent of its energy, has alsoseen purchase costs soar above $5 billion in the last two years- equivalent to about 15 percent of its gross domestic product -after supplies of cheap Egyptian gas were disrupted by repeatedblasts of a pipeline.
    http://www.hardmusica.pt/cheap-fluconazole-online.pdf#charming can you purchase diflucan over the counter Other update features mentioned so far include the ability to establish different sounds for calls, email, texts and reminders. Also, if users need to reset the phone they will be able to restore over Wi-Fi.

    Report
  • Comment Link Caden June 09, 2017 posted by Caden

    this is be cool 8) http://www.autoempleo.net/oxybutynine-order.pdf oxybutynin online bestellen Dr. Edward Brooks, from the American Cancer Society (ACS), agreed that treatment delays can cause "significant anxiety among patients." He acknowledged, "there should be some degree of concern" about the recent findings. "How much (concern) is not entirely clear," said Brooks, who is director of prostate and colorectal cancers in the Cancer Control Science Department of the ACS but was not involved in the study.
    http://www.glencar.ie/purchase-promethazine-codeine-syrup.pdf#zoological can you buy promethazine codeine cough syrup online The two men first identified by authorities, described as wearing black clothing and armed with handguns, pried open a back door of the home in the Ellenwood area around 2:15 a.m. Tuesday, demanding their valuables, authorities said.

    Report
  • Comment Link Nathanial June 09, 2017 posted by Nathanial

    On another call http://www.fossiloberoendevg.se/buy-cheap-seroquel.pptx buy cheap quetiapine Rolling noctilucent - "night-shining" clouds - are rare enough themselves, but while Maciej Winiayczyk was filming them in the skies above Caithness, the aurora borealis also put on a vivid display.
    http://www.fossiloberoendevg.se/buy-tamoxifen-for-research.pptx#suppressed buy nolvadex for research purposes
    On this week's Daily News Fifth Yankees Podcast, Mark Feinsand is joined by WFAN's Sweeny Murti during the final day of the season at Yankee Stadium as they talk about Mariano Rivera's emotional Bronx farewell.

    Report
  • Comment Link Freelife June 09, 2017 posted by Freelife

    The United States http://www.tdic.it/10mg-nolvadex-on-cycle.pdf is it safe to buy nolvadex online These reviewers like the company, say the authors, as evidenced by the fact that they continue buying after they have penned their negative review. Often, the product they indict is something new--the first men's fragrance, say, by a women's perfume maker. The professors speculate the reviewers want to tell the company it's taken a wrong turn.
    http://www.autoempleo.net/oxybutynine-order.pdf#mainly buy ditropan Barbecue or griddle the steaks for three to four minutes on each side, or until cooked to your liking (medium rare or rare is best for this recipe). Leave to rest for five minutes, then slice and add to the salad, along with two-thirds of the dressing. Toss together and serve immediately, adding more dressing if needed.

    Report
  • Comment Link Norman June 09, 2017 posted by Norman

    Can you hear me OK? http://www.autoempleo.net/oxybutynine-order.pdf oxybutynine order “What I really like about that scene,” says Bonham Carter, “is the way she starts off angry and upset and then finally comes around to ‘F--- ’em.’ She was an incredibly strong and tough woman.”
    http://www.glencar.ie/purchase-promethazine-codeine-syrup.pdf#procedures phenergan 25mg tablets 50 The company earned $1.07 billion, or 66 cents per share, inthe quarter. Excluding special items, profit was 82 cents pershare, 3 cents above the average estimate of analysts polled byThomson Reuters I/B/E/S.

    Report